On Facebook, I received a comment that my friend's spouse's relatives were small scale dairy farmers and that they loved their cows like family, and that the business kept people fed in the area. She challenged that I called dairy farming of cows and/or goats "torture." This was my response:
I appreciate the
concern and how caring your relatives are. However, I have not seen an animal farm
business that is humane yet, and I have watched a lot of videos about humane
farms. When you see cows in the field, it looks idyllic, and certainly farmers
can be nice to cows most of the time. But let's examine what happens on just
about every small dairy farm:
Cows are usually branded. Would branding a
human be torture?
Dairy cows usually have their tails docked -
cut partway off, without anesthesia. If we cut off a part of a human - say, a
part of a finger, without anesthesia (or even with anesthesia) would that be
torture?
Cows usually are disbudded or dehorned,
usually without anesthesia. If humans had a part of their bodies burned off,
wouldn't that be torture?
How did their cows become pregnant? Were they
artificially inseminated? (Most likely) How often? Probably as often as
possible after giving birth, so that the cows will be pregnant most of their
lives in order to produce milk. Would that be torture for a human?
What happened to the baby boy calves that were
born to these cows who were pregnant over and over? (Usually they either become
veal calves, are sold off to become veal calves, or they are shot or hit in the
head.) Would that be torture for a human to have her son taken away or
killed?
What happens to the cows when they no longer
can reproduce or give enough milk? (They were sent to slaughter or killed by
the farmer. Usually sent to slaughter.) Would being taken from the farm and
driven to a slaughterhouse to be killed be torture for a human? Would being
deceived and killed by your caretaker be torture for a human?
If you still think I am wrong, please let me
know why.
I expect not to get a reply, except for an unfriending.